A couple of friends recommended this book to me, so I was excited to pick it up and start it. It’s a fun blend of different classical stories, settings, and characters. By the end, I was glad to have read it; there were some rough bits in between.
A. Clarence Shandon, the eponymous Silverlock (so called for the streak of white in his hair), is clearly Eustace Clarence Scrubb all grown up. Unfortunately, traveling through the Commonwealth of Letters does not improve him as much as being dragoned by greed and un-dragoned by Aslan.
…possibly I am biased by the fact that he narrates. This being so, one sees all too far into his head. He is often driven by the basest motivation, including a bit of rather misogynistic skirt-chasing, and that’s distressingly clear throughout. The remove of a third-person narrator might have helped. As it stands, I didn’t really have the chance to develop much sympathy for him before his vices made me dislike him.
The enjoyable part is the land where he ends up. In the Commonwealth, he meets with such classical figures as Circe, Little John, Beowulf, Job, Pangloss, and some Whynnyms; he travels from the shore, to Sherwood Forest, down Watling Street, by the chapel of the Green Knight, and past Gitche Gumee (! my Michigan heart delighted in that).
So as a pastiche, it’s fairly good. Shandon is helped along by Golias, a composite of every single well-traveled bard out there: first, to survive; second, to help an asinine fellow get his girl back; third, to start off for the spring of all inspiration (a path that goes through Hell, so Shandon’s lucky Golias had his back).
(Golias, being a bard, sings a lot of songs. These are rather fun, except that I’m terrible at making up tunes as I read, so they weren’t quite as fun for me as they could have been. However! At one particular point when Golias saves Shandon’s butt, I’m preeeetty sure the song he sings scans about the same as one of Tom Bombadil’s favorites. It was an apt spot for it.)
Each scene of the picaresque was assembled nicely, and altogether it fit cunningly. But Shandon’s journeys only ever serve to make him glad to be alive for himself. He does not turn outward, glad to be of service to others. When the story finishes, he’s been changed, possibly even grown a bit…but so far as I can tell, he remains a man-shaped dragon.