Thursday Dances: Books’ Theme Songs

So.  The order of the day is Books I’d Give a Theme Song To.  This presents me with some difficulty; typically, a book’s plot or themes are more complex than any given song, and as such the song can’t necessarily represent the entirety of the book thematically…at least, not many songs I know.  Have we mentioned I don’t deal well with instrumental music?  I really have difficulty with musical comprehension without lyrics to grab hold of.

One way to circumvent both obstacles is to find a wordladen song for a not-very-wordy book: Smitten by Rachel Hale.  One of my brothers, knowing my love for kittens, gave it to me.  It’s not very involved (kittens accompany a variety of proverbs and other aphorisms), but I know the perfect song for it.

Then again, perhaps I can think of a couple stories encapsulated in song.  It’s been a while since I’ve read The Great Gatsby, but given what I recall of “the Trimalchio of West Egg,” either Richard Cory or If I Had it All would be apt.  Or, while rereading Brideshead Revisited, it would be appropriate to listen to Running Against the Sunset, This is the Time, or the outro (the last 3 minutes) of Broken Line.

But generally it’s much easier to think of a character I’d give a theme song to – or even a soundtrack!

For example, since my adolescence involved a lot of Harry Potter and a good deal of Billy Joel, certain of his songs inevitably bring Sirius Black to mind.  The man who enchanted an ordinary motorbike to fly would most certainly sing You May Be Right to whatever witch caught his fancy.  On reaching the English/wizarding drinking age (whichever comes first), he would indubitably act like a Big Shot.  And when his friends demand to know why he did such stupid things, his defense would sound an awful lot like I Go to Extremes.

Then the bomb hits.  Then they are all betrayed; then James and Lily die at Voldemort’s hand, Harry is entrusted to his relatives, and Sirius is led off to Azkaban.  It’s a completely different situation from the Vietnam War, and yet the tone of Goodnight Saigon strikes me as fitting.  Going crazy.  People getting killed around you.  Holding on to the few you can trust, and leaving more of your childhood behind with every day.  And when Sirius escapes, attempts to clear his name, rejoins the Order, and goes down in battle against Bellatrix Lestrange, I think the playlist goes from An Innocent Man to Honesty to Only the Good Die Young.

But Sirius isn’t the only one with a playlist.  More often than not, Dave Matthews Band’s tunes make me think of Severus Snape.  Given his years of love and admiration for Lily Evans, I am certain he would Sleep to Dream Her.  When the Dark Lord killed her on account of Snape’s reports of The Prophecy, he mourned that Grace is Gone.  From that moment, he was once more Captain of his own will rather than Voldemort.  He goes on living, turning against one master to serve another by brewing potions, not mutiny.  This, in some wise, serves as his penance: the unending certainty that you Pay for What You Get, and his payment is to watch over the Chosen OneHalf-Blood Prince and Deathly Hallows play out to the tune of Cry Freedom, I Did It, and What You Are.

The last of my somewhat lengthy list is not from Harry Potter and may be a bit of a cheat, I fear.  “Prelude/Angry Young Man” brings Mr. Stephen Mayfield to mind, though he is not always angry and certainly not boring.  But unfortunately for most of you, Mr. Stephen Mayfield hails from the pages of Radicals and Royalists, a book which my friend Emily is working to publish and which I have gotten to read by virtue of having edited it.  So read a bit of it here, if’n you like, and I shall let you know when you can learn more of this particular character!

9 thoughts on “Thursday Dances: Books’ Theme Songs

  1. Haha, the cat song! I’ve seen the original video, but this is the first time I’ve watched the song. On the subject of cats, I guess Andrew Lloyd Webber did the ultimate version of writing music for a book with Eliot’s Old Possum’s Book of Practical Cats.

    I like the idea of suiting songs to characters. You’re right, in some ways that is easier to choose! Most of the characters I match songs to are my own characters, not other peoples’. But that’s also in part because sometimes my stories get inspired by a song.

  2. I’ve never liked Dave Matthews, so I kind of went, “eh, ergh” when I saw that my dear Snape was matched with him. I’ve never thought too deeply about Sirius Black as a character, but I think your Billy Joel choices for him are great!

    Although I like Billy Joel, I wasn’t familiar with Angry Young Man, but after looking at the lyrics, yeah. I could see how they fit Stephen.

    • I feel like a lot of people judge DMB based on his shorter, less-involved, Top 40 songs and miss out on Two Step or Seek Up or Ants Marching (not to mention Tim Reynolds playing some excellent guitar or Boyd Tinsley rocking the fiddle). Weirdly, I feel like a lot of their songs are a bit too cheerful for Snape (weird because the overall tenor of DMB is sort of darkly shadowed).

      Re: Sirius – I know Billy Joel is something like 12 or 13 years older than Sirius, but I feel like they’d be best buds.

    • Indeed. I can’t decide whether riding a regular motorbike on wet roads is more or less dangerous than flying a motorbike through rain (and possibly rainclouds)…

  3. Man, what a collection! You really took this in intriguing directions.

    I confess the cat video terrifies me. I love cats, but… yikes!

    The lyrics of the DMB songs fit Snape quite well.

    • Haha, thanks!

      I definitely was hoisted on my own petard where the cat video was concerned – if it weren’t for Pandora, I’d be singing “Can’t hug *ev*-ry cat” to myself.
      As it is, I’m humming half of the “Remember Two Things” concert ^_^

      • Oo! A new saying! I had to look up “hoisted on my own petard,” as I have never seen or heard it before.

        As frightening as the cat-hugging song is (to me, as well as to most cats), it was David’s posting of the zombie ninja song did me in.

  4. Pingback: Conclusion « Egotist's Club

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s